Hope Springs

Posted on August 7, 2012 at 6:00 pm

Can this marriage be saved?

For decades, the Ladies Home Journal’s most popular feature has been its monthly he-said/she-said/therapist says looks at a marriage in trouble.  No matter how dire the problem — infidelity, money problems, blended family problems — somehow they (almost) always find a way to make it work.  Readers love it for three reasons.  One is the schadenfreude of reading about someone else’s misery and feeling better about our own problems.  It’s easy for fairy tale characters to live happily ever after; for the rest of us, it takes some work.  Another reason is the fun of thinking ahead to what the therapist will say to reassure us that we understand the intricacies of the relationships that for most of us are our life’s great adventure and purpose.  And third is that even more than our lives as individuals, no one is an island when it comes to marriage and whether we are married or single the strength of the relationships in the community matters to us.  Marriage can be a refuge of endless understanding and unconditional support.  Or it can be the loneliest and most desolate place on earth. Some marriages contain both.

“Hope Springs” is the name of the town an Omaha couple visits for intensive couples therapy.  And of course it is also the spirit that gets them there.  Meryl Strep is Kay, who works at a Coldwater Creek store in a mall, and Tommy Lee Jones is Arnold, a partner at an accounting firm.  They have been married for 31 years and are on a dismal sort of automatic pilot.  They sleep in different rooms and he dozes off to the Golf Channel every night.  They barely speak.  She wistfully hopes for some physical and emotional intimacy.  He does not let himself hope for anything.  She reads a book by a couples therapist and decides to spend $4000 for a week of intensive therapy in Maine, whether Arnold will go with her or not.  He is angry and uncooperative and she gets on the plane not knowing if he will join her.  At the last minute, he is there.

Arnold, still grumbling about being there and complaining about the cost of everything, is uncooperative at first.  But with gentle guidance from Dr. Feld (a sympathetic Steve Carell) he sees how important it is to Kay, and then he begins to see that it might be important to him, too.  It is very painful at times, but at least the pain is a feeling and that is better than the numbness that they have been living with.  Romantic movies are usually about people in their 20’s who fall in love.  But it is people in their 50’s and 60’s who really know what love is and how much courage it takes to stay in love.  And sometimes it takes them that long to learn that the clearest path to enduring love may not be that women’s magazine perennial, communication, but sharing laughter.  Arnold and Kay first begin to thaw when at dinner together he makes her laugh by imitating the therapist.

The story and script are nothing special, though a little less sit-com-y than the trailer suggests.  And it hurries us through the last half hour, skipping some of the emotional beats necessary to earn the ending.  If these people got married in the 1980’s, it is hard to imagine Kay would be so reluctant to speak up earlier or that Arnold would be so one-dimensional.  But Streep and Jones are pure magic, creating nuance and complexity that goes beyond the script.  The fear, the longing, the tenderness of these characters are beautifully illuminated in performances of exquisite understanding. Streep’s face as she tries to pull together to courage to walk from her bedroom to his heartbreakingly mingles hope, terror, insecurity, resilience, and attempted sexiness.  They play people we think of as ordinary.  But Streep and Jones give them the extraordinary attention that illuminates the characters with such sensitivity that we want very much to see them live happily ever after.  They show us that the luckiest among us fall in love more than once — with the same person.

Parents should know that this film has some very explicit sexual references and pretty explicit situations and some strong language.

Family discussion:  Why was it hard for Kay and Arnold to talk to each other about their feelings?  What was the most important thing they learned from therapy?  Who among your friends and family has an especially strong and enduring relationship and what makes it work?

If you like this, try: “Two for the Road”





Related Tags:


Not specified

5 Replies to “Hope Springs”

  1. Nell,

    Thank you for reviewing this movie. I must admit, although the site is supposed to help guide us about what movies our CHILDREN see, I often depend upon your reviews for movies I wish to see!

    I have not yet seen HOPE SPRINGS. I have seen the trailers, and they do make the movie look like a sit-com. However, I have also seen a clip of where Kay and Arnold talk about the first time that he told her he loved her. I was struck with the realism, the pain and the beauty, of that scene…and am now anxious to see the film. (Your B+ rating is giving me SOME pause, and I will adjust my expectations accordingly.)

    I guess as I’m getting older, I am becoming more attracted to ordinary characters and their ordinary situations. And as a middle-aged woman — one without a British accent or managerial responsibility for Men in Black/00 agents — I rejoice when films positively present Kays and Arnolds.

    1. Thanks so much, Abby. I like to think I review movies for all audiences and I am very happy when adults read my reviews to help guide their movie-going choices. Please let me know what you think when you see the movie. I hope you enjoy it.

  2. Hi Nell,

    Just a follow up as I saw the movie last night. The trailers make it look like a comedy…and Steve Carrell, known for his comic roles, makes us expect a comedy. This movie is not a comedy.

    I’m not sure I would say that I “enjoyed” the movie…it’s not necessarily a fun movie to watch. It’s painful and sad. Even some of the funny scenes (like when Kay and Arnold are in the movie theater) have a sad outcome: Kay feels like a failure, perhaps like a fake. Arnold feels bad that Kay feels bad. Yet, it was a good movie and — this is frequently a key point for me — my companion and I had much to discuss after watching it.

    1. Thanks very much, Abby. I agree with everything you said. It is a shame the film-makers were not confident enough in what they produced to be more accurate in the way they tried to sell the film in the trailer. I’m glad it sparked a good discussion.

Comments are closed.

THE MOVIE MOM® is a registered trademark of Nell Minow. Use of the mark without express consent from Nell Minow constitutes trademark infringement and unfair competition in violation of federal and state laws. All material © Nell Minow 1995-2024, all rights reserved, and no use or republication is permitted without explicit permission. This site hosts Nell Minow’s Movie Mom® archive, with material that originally appeared on Yahoo! Movies, Beliefnet, and other sources. Much of her new material can be found at Rogerebert.com, Huffington Post, and WheretoWatch. Her books include The Movie Mom’s Guide to Family Movies and 101 Must-See Movie Moments, and she can be heard each week on radio stations across the country.

Website Designed by Max LaZebnik