Teen ‘Idols’ — How to Talk to Jonas Brothers Fans

Posted on March 3, 2009 at 8:00 am

Do you have a Jonas Brothers fan in your family? Or maybe a fanatic?
Some parents have found their children’s devotion to the latest pop stars a little disconcerting. One father suggested that his daughter’s enthusiasm might merit a discussion of idolatry.
There’s a reason that they are called “idols.” Going back to Frank Sinatra and the bobby soxers before that to fan favorites like Oscar Wilde (whose fans were parodied by Gilbert and Sullivan in “Patience”), the individuals holding the position have been highly transitory but the idea of the teen idol has been enduring.
Certain themes are consistent. They may be a little edgy — sometimes a mildly transgressive element of their appearance like the Beatles’ long hair or a pierced Backstreet Boy. But overall, they tend to be reassuringly safe, slender, non-threatening, often almost pre-pubescent. Names like “Bobby,” “Ricky,” “Donny” suggest that they are almost children. Groups like the Jonas Brothers, ‘N Synch, and New Kids on the Block are popular because they give fans a chance to join in affection for the group but keep a sense of individual connection to “the cute one” or “the smart one” or “the funny one.” JonasBrothers1028x768TigerBeat.jpg
It is very important for parents to recognize that these idols are a “transition object” for tweens and young teens that is an essential step in their emotional development. In between the time when their primary focus is the home and family and the time when they will leave to begin their lives as adults, teen idols give them a chance for a dress rehearsal of some of the emotions they will feel. That does not mean that these feelings are not love or that they are not completely real. It does mean that there is an element of fantasy. Think of it as love with training wheels.
No matter how obsessively they may study the lives of these young men, they do not really know them. What they know is the carefully manufactured creation of corporate marketers. But that is just right for this stage of development because it enables them to project their own feelings onto them. It is exactly this fantasy that helps kids begin the journey to emotional maturity, the same way that playing dress-up was a way for them to begin to make sense of the adult world just a short time ago. Indeed, the love of teen idols is a form of dress-up, experimenting with some of the feelings of adulthood without the messiness of actual relationships.
Just as important, these feelings provide a bond with friends at this crucial moment when those connections are just assuming a much more significant role. Fanship gives tweens something to talk about, a private language, training wheels for what will become in their adult years the ability to talk to each other about the things that matter in a way that will strengthen their trust and respect.
Parents should respect these feelings and use them as a starting point for some important conversations. Ask them which brother they like best and why. This may be a chance to share some of your own experiences (you know that Bay City Rollers poster is still tucked away somewhere) but the focus of the conversation should be on the fan. They should reassure the child that these feelings of love are very real and an essential step toward building their ability for love and appreciation of family, romance, and even the divine.

Related Tags:


Commentary Elementary School Parenting Teenagers Tweens Understanding Media and Pop Culture

30 Replies to “Teen ‘Idols’ — How to Talk to Jonas Brothers Fans”

  1. As a husband, I wonder how many husbands out there feel that their spouse has successfully transferred all of that idol worship from their teen transition object to their long term relationship? I guess I will know if I get home tonight and find that my wife has removed the red colored M &Ms from the bowl for me.

  2. i love u nick like soooooooooo much i like dream to meet you i would really do anything i love u dont worry joe i love u alot to i love u to kevin


  4. Kevin why your no SING (i love you voice in JONAS you sing perfecte) and i love sil. Joe i love you head and you agility in concert. Nick i love you guitar sg why (nick jonas and the adminstration ??). bay i love you 3 jonas brothers

  5. i like your shows ilike to know you more my name is sharon i have the shirts of jonas brothers

  6. I love Joe Jonas.He is so nice to everyone he meets.He is going to be great in his new movie CampRock 2 the final jam.He is a great actor and a fun,loving,kind guy.

  7. That is the most ridiculous batch of excuses for being an obsessed fan that I’ve ever heard.

  8. Dolphin, I appreciate your taking the time to write, but it does not appear that you understood the post. It is not a “batch of excuses;” it is an explanation of a stage of life when young people are not yet ready to make genuine intimate connections and “try out” those feelings on impossibly distant individuals so that they can have a shared experience with their peers. What is your thought about the reason for this enduring phenomenon?

  9. These “carefully manufactured creation[s] of corporate marketers” are exploiting your daughters and forcing a premature transition into sexuality, one that is based on the adoration, idolization, and worship of men. What is the outlet for your tween’s newfound sexuality? Writing pornographic fanfiction? Experimenting with boys at school? Or maybe she does not have one and will continue to obsess and idolize men for the remainder of her life. Allowing young girls to obsess over pop stars as “transition objects” only hurts them in the long run, giving them a false identity of their own emerging sexuality, something many Jonas Brothers fans are too young to young and immature to understand.

  10. Thank you for your thoughtful comment, Concerned. I believe there is a difference between recognizing what is a natural and indeed inevitable stage of development and exploiting or inducing some perversion of normal development. Girls have been idolizing “teen idols” for a long time. Look at Gilbert and Sullivan’s “Patience” for a satire of that generation’s idols, more than a century ago. This stage can be a transition from “idolization” to a mature attachment and parents can help make sure it happens that way with their guidance and, most importantly, their example.

Comments are closed.

THE MOVIE MOM® is a registered trademark of Nell Minow. Use of the mark without express consent from Nell Minow constitutes trademark infringement and unfair competition in violation of federal and state laws. All material © Nell Minow 1995-2024, all rights reserved, and no use or republication is permitted without explicit permission. This site hosts Nell Minow’s Movie Mom® archive, with material that originally appeared on Yahoo! Movies, Beliefnet, and other sources. Much of her new material can be found at Rogerebert.com, Huffington Post, and WheretoWatch. Her books include The Movie Mom’s Guide to Family Movies and 101 Must-See Movie Moments, and she can be heard each week on radio stations across the country.

Website Designed by Max LaZebnik